(210) 201-3096
San Antonio Witness Tampering Lawyer: Tampering With a Witness Under Penal Code § 36.05
Tampering with a witness, under Penal Code § 36.05, is trying to influence a witness in an official proceeding by offering a benefit or by coercion. Outside a criminal case it is a third-degree felony. Inside a criminal prosecution it takes the grade of the most serious offense charged in that case, so it can be anything from a misdemeanor to a first-degree felony. When the underlying case involves family violence, it is never lower than a third-degree felony. That is why a San Antonio witness tampering lawyer has to read two charging documents, not one.
What the State must prove under § 36.05
Under subsection (a), the State must prove the person acted with intent to influence a witness or prospective witness in an official proceeding, and either offered, conferred, or agreed to confer a benefit on the witness, or coerced the witness. It must also prove the aim, which has to be one of these five:
- Testify falsely.
- Withhold any testimony, information, document, or thing.
- Elude legal process summoning the witness to testify or supply evidence.
- Stay away from an official proceeding the witness has been legally summoned to.
- Abstain from, discontinue, or delay the prosecution of another person.
In Chapter 36, a "benefit" is anything reasonably regarded as pecuniary gain or pecuniary advantage, including a benefit to someone whose welfare the witness has a direct and substantial interest in (§ 36.01(3)). "Coercion" is a threat, however communicated, of a kind listed in § 1.07(a)(9), such as a threat to commit an offense, to cause bodily injury in the future, or to accuse someone of an offense. An "official proceeding" is any administrative, executive, legislative, or judicial proceeding that may be conducted before a public servant (§ 1.07(a)(33)), not only a criminal trial.
Subsection (b) makes it a separate offense for the witness to knowingly solicit, accept, or agree to accept a benefit on the understanding that the witness will do one of the five things.
Subsection (e-3) adds a route in family violence cases: an act of family violence committed partly to make the witness unavailable, or to keep the witness from complying, counts as coercion.
Punishment ranges for tampering with a witness
The first five lines apply when the underlying case does not involve family violence. In a criminal case, the grade follows the most serious offense charged in that case.
- Proceeding outside a criminal case (third degree): 2 to 10 years in prison, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(d), 12.34)
- Underlying Class B misdemeanor case (Class B): up to 180 days in jail, fine up to $2,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(d), 12.22)
- Underlying Class A misdemeanor case (Class A): up to 1 year in jail, fine up to $4,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(d), 12.21)
- Underlying state jail felony case (state jail felony): 180 days to 2 years in a state jail, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(d), 12.35)
- Underlying capital felony case (first degree): 5 to 99 years or life, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(e), 12.32)
- Family violence case (third degree or the underlying grade, whichever is greater): 2 to 10 years, or the higher range of the underlying charge, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(e-1), 12.34)
- Family violence case with a prior family violence conviction (second degree or the underlying grade, whichever is greater): 2 to 20 years, or the higher range of the underlying charge, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 36.05(e-2), 12.33)
An underlying third-, second-, or first-degree felony makes the tampering charge the same degree. A state jail felony range can move up or down under §§ 12.35(c), 12.425, and 12.44. The family violence definition in Family Code § 71.004 includes dating violence. Under § 36.05(f), conduct that is also another crime can be prosecuted under both laws.
Life after a tampering conviction
A felony conviction brings the firearm limits of Penal Code § 46.04: no possession at all until five years after release from confinement or supervision, whichever is later, and after that only at the home where the person lives. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), separately bars anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year from possessing a firearm, with no five-year limit and no home exception. Whether a record can later be sealed depends on the offense and the outcome. Anyone who is not a United States citizen needs advice about immigration consequences before entering any plea.
How a tampering charge moves through Bexar County
After an arrest, the person sees a magistrate, often at the Magistrate's Office on Comal Street, where bond is set on the new charge. The Bexar County District Attorney's Office decides what to file. A tampering charge graded as a Class A or B misdemeanor goes to a Bexar County Court at Law. A felony charge is ordinarily presented to a grand jury, and an indicted case goes to a district court at the Cadena-Reeves Justice Center or the Bexar County Courthouse. When the underlying case is an assault on a family member, the family violence page covers it.
What this office examines in a witness tampering case
Intent comes first. The State must prove the person meant to influence the witness toward one of the five listed aims. An apology, or a message about money owed for some other reason, is not the same as an offer made to change testimony. The messages, read in full and in order, are the evidence.
Next, a benefit must be something reasonably regarded as pecuniary gain or advantage, and a threat must fit a category in § 1.07(a)(9), unless the State relies on an act of family violence under subsection (e-3).
Then there is the defense in § 36.05(c). For a charge under the fifth aim, delaying or ending a prosecution, it is a defense that the benefit was reasonable restitution for damages the complaining witness suffered from the offense, and that it came out of an agreement negotiated with the assistance or acquiescence of the prosecutor handling the case.
Finally, how the State got the messages or recordings it relies on. Under Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.23, evidence obtained in violation of the law may not be used against the accused at trial. Statements get the same scrutiny (see the post on confessions).
Questions people ask about witness tampering in Texas
Is witness tampering a felony in Texas?
Often, but not always. When the official proceeding is something other than a criminal case, such as a civil lawsuit or an administrative hearing, it is a third-degree felony. When the proceeding is part of a criminal prosecution, it carries the same grade as the most serious offense charged there, which can be a misdemeanor. In a family violence case, it is at least a third-degree felony, and at least second degree with a prior family violence conviction.
Can I talk to the person who accused me?
Section 36.05 does not forbid all contact. It forbids offering a pecuniary benefit, or coercing, to influence a witness toward one of five ends, such as testifying falsely. But bond conditions or a protective order may separately bar contact, and a message can be read in ways the sender never meant. Talk to a lawyer first.
Can I pay the complainant back to settle the case?
Only in a narrow way. For a charge based on ending or delaying a prosecution, Section 36.05(c) gives a defense when the payment is reasonable restitution for damages caused by the offense and comes from an agreement negotiated with the assistance or acquiescence of the prosecutor on the case. A private payment in exchange for dropping charges does not fit that defense. This post covers what happens when a complainant wants charges dropped.
What to do if you are charged with witness tampering
If you are charged with tampering with a witness, stop contacting anyone connected to the case. Call (210) 201-3096, or write through the contact form.
By Christian O. Vega, Attorney at Law
The Law Office of Christian Vega · 130 E Travis St, Suite 425, San Antonio, Texas 78205
Texas State Bar No. 24121180
Charged in Bexar County? Talk to a lawyer before your first court date.
Free, confidential consultation. Flat fees and flexible payment plans.