(210) 201-3096
San Antonio Insurance Fraud Lawyer: Claims, Applications, and Kickbacks
Insurance fraud in Texas is defined by Penal Code § 35.02. It covers false or misleading material statements made to support a claim or a policy application, and benefits solicited, offered, paid, or received in connection with goods or services for which a claim is submitted. A claim or benefit charge is graded by the value of the claim, from a Class C misdemeanor under $100 up to a first-degree felony at $300,000 or more. A false application is a state jail felony regardless of amount. For a San Antonio insurance fraud lawyer, the first questions are which subsection the State is using and how it reached its number.
The elements of insurance fraud under § 35.02
Every version requires intent to defraud or deceive an insurer. The claim and application versions also require that the person knew the statement held false or misleading material information, so a statement the person honestly believed was accurate does not fit them.
False claims, § 35.02(a). To support a claim for payment under a policy, the person prepared a statement (or caused one to be prepared) knowing it held false or misleading material information, and it was presented to an insurer; or the person presented such a statement or caused it to be presented.
False applications, § 35.02(a-1). The same conduct, but in support of an application for a policy.
Benefits and kickbacks, § 35.02(b). The person solicited, offered, paid, or received a benefit in connection with furnishing goods or services for which a claim is submitted under a policy.
The information must be material. Under § 35.015, a statement is material if it could have affected eligibility for coverage, the amount paid on a claim, or the insurer's decision whether to issue a policy. And under § 35.02(h), if the accused submitted a bill for goods or services in support of a claim to the insurer issuing the policy, the law presumes, subject to rebuttal, that the person caused the claim to be prepared or presented.
Punishment for insurance fraud in Texas
- Claim under $100 (Class C): no jail, fine up to $500 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(1), 12.23)
- Claim $100 to under $750 (Class B): up to 180 days in jail, fine up to $2,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(2), 12.22)
- Claim $750 to under $2,500 (Class A): up to 1 year in jail, fine up to $4,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(3), 12.21)
- Claim $2,500 to under $30,000 (state jail felony): 180 days to 2 years in a state jail, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(4), 12.35)
- False application, any amount (state jail felony): 180 days to 2 years in a state jail, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(d), 12.35)
- Claim $30,000 to under $150,000 (third degree): 2 to 10 years in prison, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(5), 12.34)
- Claim $150,000 to under $300,000 (second degree): 2 to 20 years in prison, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(6), 12.33)
- Claim $300,000 or more, or conduct risking death or serious bodily injury (first degree): 5 to 99 years or life, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 35.02(c)(7), 12.32)
The risk provision covers claim and benefit offenses whatever the claim's size; the statute speaks of placing a person at risk, not of actual injury.
Value is usually the total amount claimed. If that is not readily ascertainable, § 35.025 uses fair market value at the time and place of the offense, or replacement cost within a reasonable time; if neither can be determined, the value is treated as $750 or more but less than $2,500. If the accused proves by a preponderance of the evidence that part of the claim was a valid, covered loss, that part is subtracted.
Under § 35.03, claims made under one scheme or continuing course of conduct may be added together to set the grade, or, with three or more claims, the offense may be raised one category above the most serious single offense proven from those claims (a first-degree felony stays first degree).
State jail felony ranges can move: §§ 12.35(c) and 12.425 raise them for a deadly weapon finding or certain prior felonies, and § 12.44 allows Class A punishment or, on the prosecutor's request, prosecution as a Class A misdemeanor. Prior felony convictions can also raise the third-, second-, and first-degree ranges under § 12.42.
Restitution, firearms, and other consequences
Section 35.02(e) requires the court to order a convicted defendant to pay restitution to the affected insurer, including court costs and attorney's fees. Under § 35.02(f), the same conduct may be charged under § 35.02, under another statute such as theft, or both.
Under Penal Code § 46.04(a), a person convicted of a felony may not possess a firearm until five years after release from confinement or supervision, whichever is later, and after that only where the person lives. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), separately bars possession by anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year, with no five-year limit and no home exception.
Whether a record can later be sealed depends on the offense and the outcome; see the expunction and nondisclosure page. Non-citizens need advice about immigration consequences before any plea.
How an insurance fraud case moves through Bexar County
After an arrest, bond is set before a magistrate, usually at the Magistrate's Office on Comal Street. The Bexar County District Attorney's Office decides what to file, and under § 35.04 the Texas Attorney General may assist or prosecute when the local prosecutor asks.
A Class A or B charge goes to a Bexar County Court at Law; a Class C charge is heard in a justice court or municipal court. A felony is presented to a grand jury, and if it returns an indictment the case goes to a district court at the Cadena-Reeves Justice Center or the Bexar County Courthouse.
Points this office examines in an insurance fraud case
Intent and knowledge. Claim forms may be filled out by agents, contractors, or relatives. The record has to show who wrote what, and what this person knew.
Materiality. Whether the statement could have changed coverage, payment, or the decision to issue the policy, judged against the policy and underwriting files.
Value. How the claim was totaled, whether market or replacement value was applied correctly, whether a valid portion should come off under § 35.02(g), and whether aggregation was charged properly.
The paper trail. Adjuster recordings, investigator reports, and bills are checked. Evidence from an unlawful search may be excluded under Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.23, and statements to a detective are reviewed too.
Questions people ask about insurance fraud in Texas
Is exaggerating an insurance claim a crime in Texas?
It can be. Section 35.02(a) covers a statement supporting a claim that the person knows contains false or misleading material information, made with intent to defraud or deceive the insurer. When part of the claim was a valid covered loss, the accused may prove that portion, and only the remainder sets the grade.
What if I lied on an application, not a claim?
Section 35.02(a-1) covers a false or misleading material statement supporting an application for a policy, made with intent to defraud or deceive. Under § 35.02(d), it is a state jail felony whatever the amount: 180 days to 2 years in a state jail and a fine up to $10,000, subject to §§ 12.35(c), 12.425, and 12.44.
Can several small claims become a felony?
It can. Under § 35.03, claims made under one scheme or continuing course of conduct may be combined so their total sets the grade. With three or more claims, the State may instead raise the offense one category above the most serious single offense it proves from those claims.
Talk to a lawyer about an insurance fraud charge
Keep a copy of every form you signed and every bill you sent the insurer. Don't return the detective's call until you've talked to a lawyer. Call (210) 201-3096, or send the details through the contact form.
By Christian O. Vega, Attorney at Law
The Law Office of Christian Vega · 130 E Travis St, Suite 425, San Antonio, Texas 78205
Texas State Bar No. 24121180
Charged in Bexar County? Talk to a lawyer before your first court date.
Free, confidential consultation. Flat fees and flexible payment plans.