San Antonio Evading Arrest Lawyer: Flight, the Car, and Section 38.04

The lights come on behind him on I-35, a little after one in the morning. The shoulder is narrow and dark, and passing trucks rock the car. So he signals, keeps going, and takes the next exit to a lit gas station. He pulls in under the canopy, parks, and puts his hands on the wheel. He meant it as caution. The officer's report may call it something else: a driver who saw the lights and chose not to stop. Most evading arrest cases in Texas come down to that gap between what he meant and what the report says, and it is the first thing a San Antonio evading arrest lawyer asks about.

Put plainly, evading arrest or detention under Texas Penal Code § 38.04 is intentional flight from a person you know is a peace officer who is lawfully trying to arrest or detain you. On foot, a first offense is a Class A misdemeanor. Flight in a car is charged as a third-degree felony, and serious injury or death raises the grade further. Every word of the offense, from "intentionally" to "lawfully," is something the State has to prove.

What the State has to prove

Section 38.04(a) has four parts, and each is a separate burden for the prosecutor.

The first is flight. The statute does not define it. A driver who goes on to a safer place to stop has moved; whether he fled is a question for the jury. The second is intent: the flight must have been his conscious objective. Fear of a dark shoulder, confusion, or not seeing the lights at all may not be a choice to run. The third is knowledge. The State must prove he knew the person behind him was a peace officer, and an unmarked car or a plainclothes officer shouting in the dark can make that a real question.

The fourth is the one people overlook. The officer must have been attempting lawfully to arrest or detain. If there was no lawful basis for the stop, an element of the offense is missing. The reason for the original stop is part of the evading case itself.

Punishment for evading arrest in Texas

• On foot, first offense: Class A misdemeanor: Up to 1 year in jail; fine up to $4,000 (38.04(b); 12.21)
• On foot, prior evading conviction: state jail felony: 180 days to 2 years in state jail; fine up to $10,000 (38.04(b)(1); 12.35)
• Vehicle, first offense: third-degree felony: 2 to 10 years in prison; fine up to $10,000 (38.04(b)(2)(A); 12.34)
• Vehicle with a prior evading conviction, or serious bodily injury from the officer's attempt to apprehend: third-degree felony: 2 to 10 years in prison; fine up to $10,000 (38.04(b)(2); 12.34)
• Death from the officer's attempt to apprehend: second-degree felony: 2 to 20 years in prison; fine up to $10,000 (38.04(b)(3); 12.33)

Evading in a vehicle is charged in Texas as a third-degree felony. Anyone reading the Penal Code will also find a conflicting 2011 version of § 38.04(b) that calls a first vehicle flight a state jail felony; the two texts were passed in the same session, and the Code still prints both.

A car can also be a deadly weapon. Penal Code § 1.07 defines the term to include anything that, in the manner of its use, is capable of causing death or serious bodily injury. If the judgment carries a deadly-weapon finding, Code of Criminal Procedure article 42A.054 takes judge-ordered community supervision off the table, and Government Code § 508.145(d) delays parole eligibility until the person has served half the sentence in calendar time, with a two-year minimum. For a state jail felony, § 12.44 runs the other direction, allowing misdemeanor punishment.

Consequences outside the courtroom

A felony conviction reaches firearms. Penal Code § 46.04 makes it a crime for a person convicted of a felony to possess a firearm within five years of release from confinement or supervision, and after that anywhere other than where he lives. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), separately bars anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year from possessing a firearm, with no five-year limit and no home exception.

Records last longer than sentences. Deferred adjudication, where the court withholds a finding of guilt, can lead to an order of nondisclosure. For a first-time misdemeanor evading charge, Government Code § 411.072 directs the court to issue the order on successful discharge. For a felony, § 411.0725 allows a petition five years after discharge, with no new offense along the way. Anyone who is not a United States citizen should get advice about immigration consequences before entering any plea.

How the case moves in Bexar County

After an arrest in San Antonio, bond is usually set at the Magistrate's Office on Comal Street. A misdemeanor evading charge is heard in a Bexar County Court at Law. A vehicle case, or anything charged as a felony, goes to the Bexar County District Attorney's Office for grand jury review and, if indicted, to a district court, with settings at the Cadena-Reeves Justice Center or the Bexar County Courthouse.

Evading charges rarely arrive alone. They ride with whatever the officer was investigating: a traffic offense, a DWI, a warrant, a drug possession allegation.

What this office looks at in an evading arrest case

The work starts with the original stop, because the statute makes its lawfulness an element. What did the officer see before the lights came on, and does the dash camera show it? Evidence gathered after an unlawful stop may be excluded under Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.23.

Then the timeline. Patrol and body camera video show how long the lights were on, how far and how fast the car went, and where it stopped. Those facts are the raw material of the intent question.

Then knowledge: whether the car was marked, whether a siren sounded. In an injury case, whether the injury was a direct result of the officer's attempt to apprehend, as the statute requires. Finally, statements, and how they were obtained; see when a confession can be thrown out.

Questions people ask about evading arrest in Texas

Is evading arrest a felony in Texas?

On foot, a first offense is a Class A misdemeanor under Penal Code § 38.04. With a prior evading conviction it is a state jail felony. Flight in a vehicle is charged as a third-degree felony. Serious bodily injury caused by the officer's attempt to apprehend makes it a third-degree felony, and a death makes it a second-degree felony.

Can I be charged with evading if I pulled over somewhere safer?

You can be charged, but the State still has to prove intentional flight. A driver who signals, slows, and stops at the first well-lit place may not have fled at all. Distance, speed, how long the lights were on, and the video decide it.

What is the difference between evading arrest and resisting arrest?

Evading under § 38.04 is flight from a lawful arrest or detention and requires no force. Resisting under § 38.03 is using force against an officer to prevent an arrest, search, or transportation, and the unlawfulness of the arrest is no defense. Resisting is a Class A misdemeanor, or a third-degree felony if a deadly weapon is used.

Does it matter if the officer had no reason to stop me?

Yes. Section 38.04 requires that the officer was attempting lawfully to arrest or detain you. If the stop had no lawful basis, the State is missing an element of the offense. It is one of the first things examined in any evading case.

Back under the canopy

The driver under the gas station canopy stopped where he could see and be seen. Whether that last mile on I-35 was flight or caution is a question of intent, and the State carries it, along with the lawfulness of the stop that started everything. Christian O. Vega, the San Antonio Criminal Defense Lawyers Association's 2023-2024 Young Lawyer of the Year, reviews those questions with people before their first setting. The office number is (210) 201-3096, and messages can also be sent through the contact form.

By Christian O. Vega, Attorney at Law

The Law Office of Christian Vega · 130 E Travis St, Suite 425, San Antonio, Texas 78205

Texas State Bar No. 24121180

This is an attorney advertisement. Christian O. Vega is responsible for the content of this page. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes in any future case. The information here is general legal information about Texas law, not legal advice for your specific situation. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship.