(210) 201-3096
San Antonio 911 Abuse Lawyer: Silent and Abusive Calls to 9-1-1 in Texas
Texas calls this offense silent or abusive calls to 9-1-1 service, under Penal Code § 42.061. It is committed by calling 9-1-1, or requesting 9-1-1 service with an electronic communications device, when there is no emergency, and knowingly or intentionally staying silent or making abusive or harassing statements to the call-taker. A separate subsection reaches a person who knowingly lets someone else use a phone under his control that way. The offense is a Class B misdemeanor. It is a small charge on paper, but it carries possible jail time and a record, and a San Antonio 911 abuse lawyer starts with whether the State can prove the required mental state.
The elements of a § 42.061 charge
Under § 42.061(b), the State has to prove each of these beyond a reasonable doubt:
- The person made a call to a 9-1-1 service, or requested 9-1-1 service using an electronic communications device.
- There was not an emergency at the time.
- The person acted knowingly or intentionally.
- The person either remained silent or made "abusive or harassing statements to a PSAP employee."
A PSAP is a public safety answering point, defined in Health and Safety Code § 771.001 as a continuously operated facility assigned to receive 9-1-1 calls.
Under § 42.061(c), a person also commits the offense by knowingly permitting a device under his control, including a telephone, to be used by another person in a manner described in subsection (b). The State must prove that the person knowingly permitted the use, not only that the phone was under his control.
Section 42.061 defines neither "emergency" nor "abusive or harassing," and it lists no defense, so the facts of the call matter.
Three nearby offenses differ. False alarm or report under § 42.06 requires a report of an emergency the person knows is false or baseless, and § 42.0601 covers a report the person knows is false that causes an emergency response; more on the false alarm page. Interference with an emergency request for assistance under § 42.062 is knowingly preventing or interfering with another person's ability to call for help (see the interference with emergency call page). Harassment under § 42.07 requires an intent to harass, annoy, alarm, abuse, torment, or embarrass another, an element § 42.061 does not contain; see the harassment page.
What a conviction can bring
- Silent or abusive call to 9-1-1 (Class B): up to 180 days in jail, fine up to $2,000 (Penal Code §§ 42.061(b), (d), 12.22)
- Permitting another to use your device (Class B): up to 180 days in jail, fine up to $2,000 (Penal Code §§ 42.061(c), (d), 12.22)
- Repeat offender (Class B with a prior Class A or B misdemeanor or felony conviction): 30 to 180 days in jail, fine up to $2,000 (Penal Code §§ 42.061(d), 12.43(b))
Under § 12.43(b), the repeat-offender range applies when the prior conviction is shown on the trial of the case. The prior does not have to be for the same offense.
Effects that reach past the sentence
Under Government Code § 411.172(a)(4), a person charged with a Class B misdemeanor is not eligible for a license to carry a handgun while the charge is pending. Under § 411.172(a)(8), a person convicted of a Class B misdemeanor in the five years before the application is not eligible. Whether a record can later be sealed depends on the offense and the outcome; the expunction and nondisclosure page explains the general rules. Anyone who is not a United States citizen needs advice about immigration consequences before entering any plea.
The path of a Class B case in Bexar County
If there is an arrest, the person goes before a magistrate, usually at the Magistrate's Office on Comal Street, where bond is set. The Bexar County District Attorney's Office decides whether to file the charge. A Class B misdemeanor is heard in a Bexar County Court at Law. From there it moves through settings and discovery toward a resolution or a trial.
Questions this office asks in a 9-1-1 case
Who was holding the phone. A call log shows which phone was used, not by itself who was holding it, and under subsection (c) the State must show the owner knowingly allowed the use.
What the person knew. A silent call is an offense only if the silence was knowing or intentional. The recording, the length of the open line and background sound bear on that.
Whether there was an emergency, since the statute applies only "when there is not an emergency," and what was actually said, which means the recording itself rather than a summary in a report.
How the evidence was gathered. Under Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.23, evidence obtained in violation of the law may not be used against the accused at trial.
Questions people ask about 911 abuse in Texas
Is an accidental pocket dial to 911 a crime in Texas?
Section 42.061(b) requires proof that the person made the call when there was no emergency and knowingly or intentionally remained silent. Those are the only mental states the section names; it does not make a call the person did not know about an offense. The State has to prove the required mental state from the evidence.
Can I be charged if someone else used my phone to call 911?
Yes, if the State can prove you knowingly permitted it. Section 42.061(c) makes it an offense to knowingly permit a device under your control, including a telephone, to be used by another person to make a silent or abusive 9-1-1 call. The subsection requires proof that you knowingly permitted the use; control of the phone alone does not meet that element.
Is being rude to a 911 dispatcher illegal?
The statute covers "abusive or harassing statements to a PSAP employee," made knowingly or intentionally on a call placed when there is not an emergency. It does not define those words. Subsection (b) applies only to a call made "when there is not an emergency," so the absence of an emergency is part of what the State must prove. The section does not define "emergency."
Before you answer questions about the calls
Talk to a lawyer before you answer an officer's questions about the calls. If an officer has asked you about calls from your number, call (210) 201-3096, or write through the contact form.
By Christian O. Vega, Attorney at Law
The Law Office of Christian Vega · 130 E Travis St, Suite 425, San Antonio, Texas 78205
Texas State Bar No. 24121180
Charged in Bexar County? Talk to a lawyer before your first court date.
Free, confidential consultation. Flat fees and flexible payment plans.