(210) 201-3096
McAllen Evading Arrest Lawyer: Fleeing an Officer in Hidalgo County
Texas calls this offense evading arrest or detention, under Penal Code § 38.04. The core crime is intentionally fleeing from someone you know is a peace officer who is lawfully trying to arrest or detain you. On foot, with no earlier evading conviction, it is a Class A misdemeanor. A prior conviction under the same section makes it a state jail felony. Fleeing in a vehicle has been treated by Texas appellate courts as a third-degree felony, for reasons explained below. Injury or death can raise the grade. For a McAllen evading arrest lawyer, the first questions are whether the stop was lawful and whether the person knew it was the police.
The elements the State must prove under § 38.04
Each must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt:
- The person intentionally fled.
- He knew the person trying to stop him was a peace officer (or a federal special investigator).
- The officer was attempting to arrest or detain him.
- The attempt was lawful. The statute says "attempting lawfully to arrest or detain," so an unlawful detention does not support the charge.
"Vehicle" comes from Transportation Code § 541.201: a device that can carry or draw people or property on a highway.
One oddity matters here. Three 2011 bills amended § 38.04 in the same session, and the official text still prints two versions of subsection (b), the grades. One makes a first vehicle flight a state jail felony; the other makes any vehicle flight a third-degree felony. The Texas courts of appeals that have addressed the conflict have applied the third-degree version, prior conviction or not. The Court of Criminal Appeals, the State's highest criminal court, has not squarely decided it, so the grade is worth checking in each case.
Punishment ranges for evading arrest in Texas
- On foot, no prior evading conviction (Class A): up to 1 year in jail, fine up to $4,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b), 12.21)
- On foot, with a prior conviction under § 38.04 (state jail felony): 180 days to 2 years in a state jail, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(1), 12.35)
- Using a vehicle in flight (third degree, under the version courts have applied): 2 to 10 years in prison, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(2)(A), 12.34)
- Serious bodily injury during the attempt to apprehend (third degree): 2 to 10 years, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(2)(B), 12.34)
- Tire deflation device used against the officer (third degree): 2 to 10 years, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(2)(C), 12.34)
- In the course of smuggling of persons under § 20.05(a)(2) (third degree): 2 to 10 years, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b-1), 12.34)
- Death during the attempt to apprehend (second degree): 2 to 20 years, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(3), 12.33)
- Serious bodily injury from a tire deflation device (second degree): 2 to 20 years, fine up to $10,000 (Penal Code §§ 38.04(b)(3)(B), 12.33)
The two tire deflation device lines appear only in the version courts have applied; the other printed version does not mention those devices. A state jail felony is punished as a third-degree felony if a deadly weapon was used or exhibited or the person has certain listed prior felony convictions (§ 12.35(c)), and other felony convictions can raise it under § 12.425. Prior felony convictions can also raise a third- or second-degree range under § 12.42. Going the other way, § 12.44 allows a state jail felony to be punished, or on the prosecutor's request prosecuted, as a Class A misdemeanor.
What follows a conviction home
Because Penal Code § 1.07 treats anything capable of causing death or serious bodily injury in the manner of its use as a deadly weapon, the State may seek a deadly weapon finding based on how a car was driven. Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 42A.054, that finding is entered in the judgment, and art. 42A.053, the article that lets a judge place a person on community supervision, then does not apply.
A felony conviction also brings Penal Code § 46.04(a): no firearm until five years after release from confinement or supervision, whichever is later, and after that only at the place where the person lives. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), separately bars anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year from possessing a firearm, with no five-year limit and no home exception. Whether a record can later be sealed depends on the offense and the outcome; the expunction and nondisclosure page covers the general rules. A person who is not a United States citizen needs advice about immigration consequences before any plea.
How the case moves in Hidalgo County
Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 15.17, the person must be taken before a magistrate without unnecessary delay and within 48 hours. The magistrate explains the accusation and the person's rights, including the right to hire a lawyer, to remain silent, and to an examining trial, and admits the person to bail if allowed by law.
The Hidalgo County Criminal District Attorney's Office decides what to file. A Class A charge is heard in a Hidalgo County Court at Law. A felony charge, including a vehicle case, is presented to a grand jury, and an indictment sends it to a district court. Both are heard at the Hidalgo County Courthouse in Edinburg.
Where an evading case usually turns
The stop comes first. Lawfulness is an element, and Code of Criminal Procedure art. 38.23 keeps evidence obtained in violation of state or federal law out of a Texas trial.
Next are knowledge and intent. Recordings from the patrol car or the officer may show what each person could see.
Then the enhancing fact. An injury must meet the § 1.07 definition of serious bodily injury and be a direct result of the officer's attempt to apprehend.
Questions people ask about evading arrest in Texas
Is running from a stop on foot treated the same as driving away?
No. Under § 38.04, fleeing on foot is a Class A misdemeanor unless the person has an earlier evading conviction, which makes it a state jail felony. Fleeing in a vehicle is higher. The statute prints two versions of the grades, and the appellate courts that have addressed them have applied the version that makes a vehicle flight a third-degree felony even without a prior.
What if I did not realize it was the police behind me?
Knowledge is an element. The State has to prove you knew the person trying to stop you was a peace officer. Marked units, sirens, uniforms and spoken commands tend to prove it; an unmarked car at night or lights that were hard to see point the other way.
Can an evading conviction from years ago raise a new charge?
It can. Section 38.04 raises the grade when the person "has been previously convicted under this section," and the text of the section does not set a time limit on that earlier conviction. The State still has to prove the prior with records that connect it to you, and whether a particular old case qualifies is worth checking.
Can I be charged with evading and something else from the same night?
Yes. Section 38.04(d) allows prosecution under this section, the other law, or both. A common pairing is evading with the offense the officer was investigating, such as DWI (see the McAllen DWI page).
Talk to a lawyer about an evading arrest charge
Whether the stop was lawful and what you understood at the time can matter more than the word "felony" on the booking sheet. To talk about a Hidalgo County case, call the McAllen office at (956) 802-5645. Spanish-speaking callers can call (956) 630-1970. You can also write through the contact form, or see the other charges on the McAllen criminal defense page.
By Christian O. Vega, Attorney at Law
The Law Office of Christian Vega · McAllen office: 2415 N. 10th Street, McAllen, TX 78501 · (956) 802-5645
Primary office: 130 E Travis St, Suite 425, San Antonio, Texas 78205 · (210) 201-3096
Texas State Bar No. 24121180
Charged in Hidalgo County? Talk to a lawyer before your first court date.
Free, confidential consultation. Flat fees and flexible payment plans.